---
Credit: azi at Hyunnie's Pexers
According to an email that I received from Yahoo Korea in response to my queries, votes for the other contender come from overseas and there seems no reason to think that those were invalid. On the other hand, a Korean fansite was able to capture real time changes in the influx of votes and there was a very clear irregular voting pattern.
It seems like Yahoo Korea needs proof of this irregularity, in addition to the fact that we had difficulties accesing the voting site on November 27 and 28, for them to take action, so I urge whoever reading this to send a formal complaint to their customer service, links are provided below, and don’t forget to copy paste this post as an attachment to your email:
2. 야후! 코리아 고객센터Proof # 1
For the sake of analysis, let me do some trending base on the data posted below. Excluding the bulk amount of votes for contenders (i.e with green highlights), the normal voting scenario is this: in 62 minutes, Kim Hyun Joong got 22,395 votes while Jan Geun Suk got 597 in total. Further analysis : KHJ gets an average of 361.2 votes per minute while JGS gets an average of 9.63 votes only, or a mere 2.67 % of what KHJ’s total. Simply put, the votes ratio is 37:1 in favor of KHJ. If JGS managed to garner a meager 3% compared to KHJ votes, where did the bulk votes for JGS came from? Trends for increase can be ascertained by mere looking at the 3rd and 5th column below. One need not be a math expert to tell the anomalous pattern.
re-posted from: http://micon.miclub.com/board/viewArticle.do?artiNo=81955382&listCateNo=261&listPage=1
column 1 : time , column 2: KHJ Total Votes, column 3 : KHJ Increase in votes, column 4 : JGS Total Votes, column 5: JGS increase in votes
Proof # 2
re-posted from blog.daum.net/miniquilt and captured by Ralph@KHJ0606.com
This one captures the trend from 7:15 to 7:47 am 32 minutes trend. In that span of time excluding the bulk votes which is highlighted in red, KHJ got 8,621 (ave. 269.4 / minute) votes while JGS got 234 (ave. 7.31/minute) votes. If we compare it with the our 5:34 to 6:36 trend, we still get the same ratio of 37: 1 votes in favor of Kim Hyun Joong. So what does this trends tells us? Are we being deceived by our own eyes? The most important question is : WE HAVE THE FACTS, WHAT ARE WE GOING TO DO ABOUT IT?
Proof # 3
Screen captures made by Meteorflower dated 11.29.2010, wherein two different results where shown by Yahoo.
a.) Capture Time : 09:10 p.m Date : 11.29.2010
Votes: KHJ = 4,931,386
JGS = 4,182,810
b.) Capture Time : 09:18 p.m Date: 11.29.2010
Votes: KHJ = 2,555,555
JGS = 990,530
That was not the first time that Yahoo showed increasing/decreasing results in that category, it has been happening the whole day of November 29, 2010.
Proof #4
To further support that, here is another capture from blog.daum.net/miniquilt dated November 30, 2010. Take note of the time and the number of votes too.
Proof # 5
These are the most vital ones, simply because it shows how the fans of the other contender were able to amassed millions of votes in just two days. Honestly, so their idol got huge number of votes, but did they think that he will be happy to receive an award won through cheating?
Here are the screen captures of the software they used to manipulate the votes, complete with download links and tutorials, the Thailand version even have the exact coordinates!
This one is used by the Hongkong forum sukstar-hk.com (go ahead, check out their forum)
JGS fans in Thailand did the same.. they even instructed fans step by step.
So now, tell me, is this fair or what?
Please spread the word about this and send complains to Yahoo Korea. We are not doing this to gain prestige nor recognitions for Kim Hyun Joong or our fan sites, we just wanted everything to be fair, let us do our part and not let our time and efforts be wasted by losing to an AUTOCLICK!
We lost in numbers but we have not lost the war….!
kk... i'm asking my informal kr teacher to help me write the complaint..
ReplyDeletei love jang geun suk as well BUT i'm all about fairness.
why "panic mode" ?
suhyun
ps. i always thought i was more of a triple s material, rather than a hyunnie but with reflection, it doesn't seem right since i'm a LOT more obsessed with HJ than the rest of the boys per se. so i guess i'm like you. i care about the boys but in terms of fangirling, i'm more biased. the difference is that i discovered ss501 as a group first.
ReplyDeletesuhyun
i do hope they can read the conversation of JGS fans..the link seems to be removed..and their forum is private..only members can read the conversations..i hope Yahoo Korea will take this seriously.
ReplyDeleteI'm sure there are some fans who weren't involved but sadly they will get lumped in with those who did. I do not blame the actor either and have no ill will towards him but it's just not right what they did. I am sure yahoo will give him the award anyway but it's still not right. Thanks for saying you will email yahoo. That is very kind of you.
ReplyDeletejust emailed them. i'd actually prefer him to know of the situation and say something to HJ and his fans about how he feels about the matter. mabye say something to those dishonest fans too, and then decline the award, as happy as i was that he "won" in the first place, i'd be happier knowing he did the right thing.
ReplyDeleteYou are a good fan. Thank you very much. I wish they were all like you then this wouldn't be happening in the first place. I hope this all turns out good for everyone involved. It's not fair to either JS or HJ.
ReplyDeletethank you jgsholic! JGS will be proud to have a fan like you.
ReplyDeleteJGSHolic u are very reasonable. thx for understanding.If u could just explain to JGS fans regarding this matter, i'm sure they would understand and not take it as we KHJ fans are trying to bash JGS or making look bad coz as u know there really is some dishonest doing going on that helped JGS votes rise up so high that it begin causing commotions.Hope that u as a JGS fan which i respect, would help in this matter by explaining to the othe JGS fans. :)
ReplyDeletei wish all fans, regardless of who they follow, were reasonable lol i like HJ too so mabye thats why i'm able to think about this matter objectively. i've already posted about this matter on my facebook, and on the page i run on there. so far i've gotten responses of surprise from fellow eels, but i don't think any of them are from HK or thailand. idk, i'll keep posting about it tho
ReplyDeletehi all MK/PK Fans, pls help Vote MK/PK on a TOP, now it's still no.3 here;
ReplyDeletehttp://kr.rival.kids.yahoo.com/rival/favor/index.html?ac=favor&category=2&code=201012
Thanks in advance.